89% matchNotre Shop
Midwest twin: curated sneaker buy plus own label
What changes: Leans more designer/contemporary than film-narrative sneaker collabs
Brand profile
Extra Buttery NYC
Cinema-themed New York sneaker boutique and in-house label, founded 2007, known for story-driven footwear collaborations.
New York CityOrigin
UnisexFocus
StreetwearStyle
$$$Price
4 brands like Extra Buttery NYC like Notre Shop, RSVP Gallery, Woaw Store →
What to know about Extra Buttery NYC
A shop first, label second
Extra Butter is a sneaker boutique stocking Nike, Air Jordan, adidas, New Balance, Asics and Stone Island, with its own EB Collection sitting alongside those brands.
Collaborations are the reputation
Its name was built on narrative, film-referencing sneaker projects with Asics, Saucony, Reebok and Puma rather than on its own seasonal clothing.
Cinema styling, three New York doors
Founded in Rockville Centre on Long Island in 2007, it added Lower East Side and Long Island City stores, all fitted out like vintage movie theaters.
If you like Extra Buttery NYC
89% match
80% match
75% matchWoaw Store
Asia-side boutique with heavy collab program
What changes: Broader lifestyle/design mix, less sneaker-release driven
72% matchSomewhere DC
Shop-plus-cafe take on curated menswear and kicks
What changes: No in-house label of the same collab weight
Brand facts
Extra Butter is a New York sneaker boutique and in-house label founded in 2007 in Rockville Centre, Long Island, by Ankur Amin and Jason Faustino. It opened a Lower East Side store in 2013 and a Long Island City location beside MoMA PS1 in 2020. Stores are styled like vintage cinemas, and the buy mixes Nike, Air Jordan, adidas, New Balance, Asics and Stone Island with the EB Collection private label. The shop is known for narrative, film-referencing sneaker collaborations with brands including Asics, Saucony, Reebok and Puma.
- Founded
- 2007
- Origin
- New York City, United States
- Made in
- USA
- Price
- $$$
- Focus
- Unisex
- Facts checked
- September 2026
- Styles
- Streetwear, Skatewear, Minimalist / Contemporary